Cheese Stuffed Shells


Stuffed shells are another regular on our weekly dinner menu. Everyone likes them, they are easy to make and they can be made ahead. This is another childhood favorite of Rich’s. His mom almost always makes a double batch and freezes half for another meal. She likes to freeze the whole casserole, complete with sauce. I prefer to freeze just the shells in a zip-lock bag to save freezer space. When I want to bake them, I just put the frozen shells in a sauce-filled casserole dish and add about 15 minutes to the baking time.

Making the recipe as written will leave you with half a container of ricotta cheese. I can only get it in one-pound containers (well, 15 ounces, with shrinking packages these days). It keeps in the fridge for a long time, or you can use it in bacon and date calzones, on white pizza or do like the container I have suggests and mix it with vanilla and honey for a fruit dip. I like to use whole milk ricotta, it has only two more grams of fat per serving than the light and it tastes so much better. Don’t use fat-free. Trust me.

These are strictly vegetarian. You can always serve them with meat sauce or meatballs if you like. You can add spinach or garlic to the filling for another variation. For my sauce, I usually buy unseasoned crushed tomatoes and add my own garlic, basil and spices. I like the control. Use whatever sauce you prefer.

Speaking of sauce, I bake the shells on a bed of sauce, with none on top. My sauce-phobic family prefers them that way, though I top my serving at the table with the extra sauce from the bottom of the casserole dish. If you like sauce, you can put some on top before you bake them, or have extra on hand to serve at the table.

Download or print the recipe here.

Cheese Stuffed Shells
From The Cook’s Life
Serves 4-6

This is easy to double to serve a crowd or to freeze half for later meals. If freezing, you can either make two complete casseroles and freeze one, or just double the shell portion and freeze them in a zip-lock bag without the sauce. Add frozen shells to sauce and add about 15 minutes to the baking time. If freezing entire casserole, thaw in fridge overnight before baking.

½ pound large pasta shells
½ pound grated mozzarella cheese
½ pound ricotta cheese
1 egg

2 cups crushed tomatoes, low-sodium or no salt added, if possible
1-4 cloves garlic, diced
1-2 teaspoons brown sugar
1-2 teaspoons dried basil
paprika, few dashes
cayenne, few dashes
2 cups of your favorite tomato sauce

For Serving:
Parmesan cheese
Tomato sauce

Preheat oven to 350 degrees.

Cook pasta according to package directions, subtracting a few minutes from the cooking time so pasta is very al dente. It will cook more later in the oven. Drain pasta and set aside to cool while you make the filling.

Combine mozzarella cheese, ricotta cheese and egg. Mix well. Set aside.

Mix sauce ingredients together and spread in the bottom of a medium-sized shallow casserole dish.

Fill each pasta shell with about two tablespoons of cheese filling. Arrange filled shells in a single layer on top of tomato sauce.

Cover shells with foil and poke a few holes in the top to let steam out. Bake for 45-60 minutes, or until sauce is bubbling and cheese is melted and hot. Serve immediately with Parmesan cheese and extra sauce, if desired.

1 thought on “Cheese Stuffed Shells

  1. What a great recipe. I happen to have 1/4 cup less than a full container of ricotta in the fridge, and I know my daughter is a stuffed shells fan. She went to a week-long summer Elderhostel with my parents, tried them in the dorm, and came home raving about them.

    I’ll have to add shells to the grocery list–thanks!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s